anne-marie vestergaard Blog gymnasium konstruktivisme Replique 2019 Samfund skriftlighed uddannelse universitetsmarxisme

Scripture's mystery – thoughts in an exam time

The level of written communication in the Danish schooling system is reducing, regardless of an intensified concentrate on simply writing. Based on Anne-Marie Vestergaard, the problems are on account of new instructional theories, which consider that information may be written because learning comes from within. This, nevertheless, creates a niche between individuals from literally robust and weak houses.

By Anne-Marie Vestergaard

Lately, the country's censors are judging by this yr's scholar examination types in Danish. I personally have been educating around the faculty and schooling system for numerous years and, like many others, can testify that the extent of written communication isn’t notably excessive. From time to time larger schooling institutions additionally complain concerning the students' poor degree.

Ineffective efforts

It might be shocking, all the while, appreciable assets and assets have been spent on creating and strengthening the educating of the writing in the previous few years. twenty years. Much cash has been spent on improvement work and research, and new instructional theories and methods for selling and creating the pupils' written competence have steadily grow to be enshrined as paradigms in the system.

If the researchers maintain the criticism, they may sometimes object that the drop in quality has not been documented. Scientific empirical research are missing. The one factor one can relate to as a practitioner is one's personal and colleagues' experiences. It can’t be prevented that one additionally seems to be at the elementary faculty, the place the scholars come from. I personally have taught instructor schooling, and it’s a comparable view of writing and writing lessons that you simply convey there, I ought to say howdy and say.

Some years ago, the concept of “New writing” was launched, now writing was to be unfold to all topics in highschool in order to advertise studying. And a couple of years ago, the pedagogical candidates might select to put in writing assignments in theoretical pedagogy about “writing to learn”. Students must write always, each for their very own sake and for the surface world, but the capacity to formulate lags tremendously. The phrase injury is turning into increasingly in depth. A paradox.

Ellen Krogh is a longtime instructor and researcher and has, if any, been the leader of the good give attention to writing in the upper secondary faculty system. Until just lately, she was professor of the didactics of the Danish subject at the College of Southern Denmark, initially employed on the Danish Institute for Larger Schooling, which was the concrete implementation of the scientific educating of highschool pedagogy, which from the end-nineties had to reassess and qualify the academics.

Constructivist educating vision

She has also played an essential position in designing the reworked higher secondary faculty reform in 2005. Her topic is Danish, and it’s no coincidence for the formation a part of the topic lists into the problem. She and lots of different instructional researchers have the Danish topic in the back pocket, as a again loss and an unspoken premise, but not as a distinct educational content material to be conveyed from instructor to scholar. This group of scientists even has knowledgeable and academic ballast from a standard faculty system, however they however emerge with a constructivist, “progressive” view of educating and studying.

Krogh and like-minded Russian psychologist Lev Vygotsky has as the primary theorist why they assume that considering and language are interdependent. In their didactic considering it, via intermediate accounts, has as a consequence that the oral and written work continually work together and fertilize each other. So you write your learning ahead – miraculously…

Ever because the start of Ellen Krogh's research career, it has been about helping the person scholar together with his “writing development”, where the private written voice have to be developed. Because the language grows, the title of a e-book she wrote with a gaggle of colleagues associated to a improvement venture in the late nineties. As language grows, learning grows, it comes from within.

Ever since, the word move from the researchers has grown, and college students from particularly non-book houses have grow to be worse and worse at formulating themselves in writing. It stays unexplained tips on how to get the bookmakers into the (writing) culture, because the language often grows with those that have the tradition from residence. The case with Mette from When the language grows, this exhibits precisely. She has a cultural baggage together with her.

The instructor with the purple pen

The progressive schooling abolishes the instructor with the pink pen. The instructor have to be a facilitator for the scholar's improvement in the direction of turning into a talented writer. The instructor is a linguistic tutor, and it is an situation to offer suggestions in the type of a character as the scholar gets far more to understand how he can get better. Most academics have simply experienced that weak college students demand grades.

A really used e-book in educating circles is Portfolio analysis and portfolio didactics, written by Ellen Krogh in collaboration with Mi’janne Juul Jensen. In accordance with the ebook, writing in Danish educating turns into an factor of a continuing self-evaluation, the place the scholar must actively relate to his or her personal studying – and his own individual, in sets and manner. A logbook is written, and written merchandise have to be introduced in a portfolio, in the identical approach as an artist's presentation portfolio. Students must learn one another's tasks and provides suggestions, they usually must in a method train each other.

The authors appear to have revolutionized all the educating state of affairs and abolished themselves as educators: “This collective learning process helped develop knowledgeable working group in the category where students turned a sort of analysis and improvement agent who by way of didactic reflection developed analytical competence and the metavid about Danish scholarship and learning in The tone is nearly ecstatic.

Roots in college marxism

It isn’t troublesome to see the authors' roots in college Marxism in the seventies. They made up with the authoritarian academics in their time, and now they will not themselves act as authorities, might even feel discomfort. At that time, it was ideological criticism and consciousness raising of the plenty, now it applies to the scholar's important take a look at himself and the training process. The educating state of affairs in the classroom has been reworked right into a Soviet working collective. The failure of the weak scholar turns into all of the extra clear in this edition of Duty for personal studying. The 68's showdown with (instructor) authorities has in this case led to instructional theories without (instructor) authorities.

“The personal voice” and “creative exercises” have been introduced in the adjusted curricula from 2017 for the graduate and HF respectively, which is analogous to a victory for Ellen Krogh and like-minded. My Danish instructor colleagues, nevertheless, already ask the question of how the private voice could be developed by the pupils who, in their types, are on the pseudo-level and proverbial degree, and as purely syntactically writing SMS-language.

Linguistic inequality

The linguistic impotence of the pupils of the e-book is a problem the researchers are blind to. Myself and different practitioners can see an incredible polarization between language and knowledge-poor younger individuals on the one hand and linguistically refined and really knowledgeable younger individuals on the opposite. It is a polarization that very often has a socio-economic background. It’s grotesque that previous Marxists with their attitudes and strategies indirectly contribute to maintaining inequality in the schooling system.

Erik Jerlung, a long-time high school instructor, writer, translator and debater, has adopted the event of latest instructional currents through the years. In accordance with him, the threads go back partly to Rousseau, and partly to the reform schooling. In that custom, you mean that the child and the pupil study by their own power and curiosity, and the educator or the instructor have to be on the sidelines. It is principally a platonic view of learning the place information by the use of the midwife technique have to be obtained from the pupil's interior.

Paradoxically, the view of learning is given a revival of a modernity that has lengthy since discovered the duality and which means of the Second. In a Fb publish, Jerlung speaks the concept of “writing”, as it is utilized by an enthusiastic Ellen Krogh in a sales video from Gyldendal, and because it appears with great obviousness in the Ministry of Schooling's curricula and tips. “Writing” and related ideas have develop into mysterious words that everybody pretends to know the which means of. Jerlung says very witty that there isn’t any “magic spellboard” that may trigger practical illiterates to put in writing (nicely). “Writing” has turn out to be an instructional term, a sort of new language that masks actuality. The teacher-student relationship and the tutorial content, primary elements of all educating because the daybreak of time, are thus darkened.

I should assume that trendy writing pedagogy has triumphed over hell. It is part of an educational-administrative business that continuously generates new books, new courses and new jobs. It’s unbelievable that you haven’t tried from the political workforce to measure the advantages of the massive funding in “writing”, all the time our society turns into increasingly written.

The actual heroes in the present day are the various Danish academics who select to comply with their widespread sense and who assume pragmatically. They follow some form of civil disobedience, they usually might even consider their favourite academics from their own faculty hours. At the moment's hero is passionate concerning the subject, they usually each dare and need to lead the pupil into the gorgeous linguistic creations of culture.

The problem is all of the higher when the social media is a permanent temptation for the scholars, the engaging, fast repair. At the similar time, studying and writing requires rather more from the scholar than the reside pictures they have grown up with. To turn out to be a great writer, you should have learn so much – have we not all been epigones? A clever man once claimed that pedagogy was imitation, as a result of in the imitation there is a shift, and one thing new arises.

Anne-Marie Vestergaard holds a MA degree. in literary history and philosophy.

The speech The mystery of the scripture – thoughts in an exam time
was first launched on Critique.